Best Store Bought Honey Mustard 2023

Honey mustard is a delicious condiment that can add sweet and savory flavors to everything from sandwiches and wraps to chicken wings and pretzels. Made from a tasty blend of mustard and honey, this versatile sauce has become a staple at restaurants, homes, and tailgates across America.

But with so many honey mustard options on the market, how do you know which one to buy? Finding the best honey mustard for your needs depends on considering factors like ingredients, texture, taste, and price. This buying guide will walk you through everything you need to know to select a top-quality honey mustard that suits your preferences.

We’ll discuss what to look for when reading honey mustard labels, provide tips for identifying high-quality products, and recommend a few favorite brands to try. Whether you’re a honey mustard connoisseur or buying it for the first time, this guide will help you buy the best honey mustard to take your cooking and snacking to the next level!

A Tangy Twist For All Your Dipping Needs

French's Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce, 12 oz

    French’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce brings a sweet and tangy flavor to all of your favorite foods. This smooth, creamy mustard makes an irresistible dip for everything from chicken fingers and fries to pretzels and fresh veggies. The blend of real honey and premium mustard seeds gives it a mild mustard taste with a nice honey sweetness. You’ll love that it has no artificial flavors or high fructose corn syrup. French’s uses quality ingredients like honey, mustard seeds, and savory spices to create an authentic flavor you can trust. This honey mustard sauce can transform basic meals into something special. Drizzle it on top of a chicken sandwich for a burst of flavor. Or use it as a tasty marinade for chicken before grilling. Having this versatile condiment on hand means quick and easy ways to elevate family dinners any night of the week. The convenient squeeze bottle makes it simple to get the right amount. Shake well before using and refrigerate after opening. Add this pantry staple to your next grocery order and start dipping into the delicious possibilities.

    Sweet And Creamy Honey Mustard Perfect For Dipping

    Inglehoffer Sweet Honey Mustard, 10.25 Ounce Squeeze Bottle

      Inglehoffer Sweet Honey Mustard is the ideal dipping sauce to keep on hand. Its smooth, creamy texture coats food perfectly for great flavor in every bite. A blend of honey, mustard seeds, and spices gives it a sweet yet tangy taste everyone will love. Dunk chicken nuggets, fries, mozzarella sticks and more into this irresistible condiment. The squeeze bottle makes it super easy to drizzle on just the right amount. You’ll be amazed at how it elevates simple snacks into something special. Even veggies become irresistible when paired with this tasty dip. Spread it onto sandwiches and wraps give them a delicious flavor upgrade. Mix it into tuna or chicken salad for a sweet twist. Or use it to make salad dressings and marinades to add some spice and nice. The possibilities are endless with this versatile sauce. Free of artificial flavors and made with quality ingredients like real honey, you can feel good about serving Inglehoffer Sweet Honey Mustard. Keep a bottle handy in the fridge and see for yourself how much more fun eating can be when you have the perfect dip.

      Elevate Any Meal With Chick-fil-A’s Signature Sweet And Tangy Sauce

      Chick-Fil-A Sauce 8 oz. Squeeze Bottle 2 Pack- Resealable Container for Dipping, Drizzling, and Marinades (Honey Mustard)

        Transport your tastebuds to Chick-fil-A with their original honey mustard sauce. This crowd-pleasing condiment adds the fast food joint’s signature tangy sweetness to whatever you’re eating. Drizzle it over nuggets, fries, and sandwiches for instant flavor upgrade. Or use it as a dip and let the smooth, creamy texture enhance the taste of anything you’re snacking on. Chicken fingers, pretzels, and veggies all become more delicious when paired with this sauce. Add it to wraps or burgers for next-level flavor without the extra calories of eating out. Mix it into tuna, chicken or pasta salads to liven up lunchtime. When cooking at home, use it as a marinade or stirred into sauces for a mouthwatering hint of honey mustard. Having this versatile favorite on hand means quick and easy ways to recreate that Chick-fil-A taste you love. Made with natural ingredients and no artificial flavors, you can feel good about drizzling it over all your family’s meals and snacks. The convenient squeeze bottle ensures mess-free dipping and pouring. Spice up dinnertime, amp up appetizers, and take your at-home cooking to the next level with the bold, sweet flavor of Chick-fil-A’s honey mustard sauce.

        Sweet And Tangy Honey Mustard Perfect For All Your Snacks And Meals

        Sweet Baby Ray's Dipping Sauce, Honey Mustard (14 Fl Oz (Pack of 4))

          Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce will become your new favorite condiment. It has the ideal balance of spicy and sweet everyone will love. A blend of bold mustard and golden honey makes this versatile sauce irresistible. Dunk nuggets, fries, or crunchy veggies into this creamy dip for an instant flavor boost. Drizzle it over wraps and sandwiches to spice them up. Use it to marinate chicken or pork before grilling for extra juicy and delicious results. Mix it into tuna or pasta salad for a tasty twist. Having this do-it-all condiment on hand means quick ways to improve every meal. Sweet Baby Ray’s uses quality ingredients like honey, mustard seeds, and savory spices to create authentic flavor. Free of artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives, you can feel good about serving this sauce. Thanks to the squeeze bottle, it couldn’t be easier to get the right amount to drizzle, dip or spread. Make snack time more exciting, add zing to sandwiches, and bring new life to leftovers with this versatile honey mustard. Keep it stocked in the fridge to elevate family dinners, pack more flavor into lunches, and enjoy the sweet tanginess you love anytime.

          Big Bottle Of Honey Mustard Perfect For Restaurants And Big Families

          French's Honey Mustard, 105 oz - One 105 Ounce Container of Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce, Best for Use on Sandwiches, Burgers, Sides and More

            This extra large size of French’s Honey Mustard means always having enough of this versatile condiment on hand. The smooth, creamy texture and sweet tangy flavor make it a tasty addition to so many foods. Sandwiches, burgers, chicken fingers, fries, and veggies all get an upgrade when paired with this mustard. Restaurants and big families will appreciate having plenty in stock at all times. French’s uses a traditional stone grinding method along with the best mustard seeds to achieve unmatched quality and flavor. Real honey gives it a nice sweetness that perfectly balances the mild mustard taste. Made with no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives, you can feel confident serving this sauce. Use the large volume pump dispenser to easily get just the right amount. Drizzle it over pulled pork sandwiches for a delicious finishing touch. Mix it into coleslaw, tuna salad, or deviled eggs for a tasty twist. Brush it onto chicken before baking for juicy, flavorful results every time. Having plenty of this sweet and tangy mustard on hand means you’ll never run out of ways to make meals more delicious for family, friends, and customers.

            Delight Your Tastebuds with This Sweet and Tangy Honey Mustard

            Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Honey Mustard Dressing, 16 Fl Oz

              If you love the combination of savory and sweet, then you need to try Amazon’s Happy Belly Honey Mustard Dressing. This is a must-have condiment that takes sandwiches, salads, chicken tenders and more to the next level.

              What really makes this honey mustard stand out is the well-balanced flavor. You get the sweetness from the honey blended with the tanginess of mustard – it creates such an addictive taste! I find that many honey mustards are too sweet, but this one has the perfect amount of honey flavor. Each bite makes your tastebuds sing.

              When you first open the bottle, the bright yellow color will catch your eye. I love the cheerful color paired with the clear bottle – it just looks so appetizing! The honey mustard pours out nice and smooth, with a creamy, easy-to-spread consistency. It coats sandwiches and vegetables flawlessly without being too thick or drippy.

              This dressing is so versatile – drizzle it on top of a fresh garden salad for added zing, use it as a tasty dipping sauce for chicken nuggets, or slather it on a ham and Swiss sandwich to take the flavors to new heights. I also love to whisk it into potato salad or pasta salad recipes. The options are endless!

              For the quality and delicious honey mustard flavor, Happy Belly brand is a bargain. This will quickly become a refrigerator staple you can’t live without. Give your meals a sweet and tangy kick by adding this must-have condiment today!

              Spice Up Your Meals with Horseradish Mustard’s Zesty Kick

              Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Honey Mustard, Kosher, 12 Ounce

                Searching for a condiment with big, bold flavor that can spice up any meal? Look no further than Amazon’s Happy Belly Horseradish Mustard! The addition of horseradish gives this mustard a peppery, sinus-clearing kick that adds excitement to sandwiches, sausages, dips and more.

                As soon as you open the bottle, you’ll notice the eye-catching bright yellow color. It looks so vibrant and appetizing. The mustard has a smooth, creamy texture that spreads easily without being overly thick or runny.

                The flavor is an absolute explosion of tangy, spicy goodness in your mouth. You get the heat from the horseradish paired with mustard’s signature zingy taste. Each bite makes your tastebuds stand up and take notice. It has the perfect amount of spiciness to add big flavor without being overwhelming.

                I love using this horseradish mustard to spice up basic hot dogs and brats on the grill. It also does wonders to wake up a boring turkey sandwich or burger. Mix it into potato salad, deviled eggs or creamy dips for a flavorful kick. The options are endless with this versatile condiment.

                For those looking to add excitement and flair to meals, you can’t go wrong with Happy Belly’s Horseradish Mustard. The bold, peppery flavor will become a staple in your refrigerator in no time. Spice up your dishes today!

                Boar’s Head Honey Mustard: A Tantalizing Blend of Sweet and Savory

                Boar's Head, Honey Mustard, 10.5 oz

                  For a top-quality honey mustard made with premium ingredients, look no further than Boar’s Head Honey Mustard. This is a gourmet condiment that will add sweet, tangy flavor to all of your favorite foods.

                  As soon as you open the jar, the bright golden color leaps out at you. It’s so vivid and appealing! I love that Boar’s Head uses whole mustard seeds that are freshly ground to create an ultra-smooth texture and mild mustard base. Then they blend in golden honey, horseradish and spices to create magic.

                  That first taste is incredible – you get a perfect balance of sweet honey flavor paired with mustard’s signature tang. It glides over your tastebuds so smoothly. This isn’t one of those cloyingly sweet honey mustards that overwhelms – it finds that ideal sweet spot.

                  While this honey mustard is on the milder side, you get subtle notes of horseradish that provide a gentle kick. It adds even more depth and character to the flavor.

                  Drizzle this gourmet condiment over chicken, slather on sandwiches, or use it to dress up salads. It’s also fantastic as a dipping sauce for appetizers like pretzels or fried veggies. However you use it, the tantalizing blend of sweet and savory is sure to become a favorite!

                  Add Sweetness to Your Day with Honeycup Mustard

                  Honeycup Mustard, 8 oz

                    For a honey mustard with the perfect balance of sweet and tangy, you need to try Honeycup Mustard! This is my absolute favorite condiment for adding a touch of honey sweetness to sandwiches, chicken tenders and more.

                    As soon as you open the squeeze bottle, the vibrant golden color makes your mouth water in anticipation. And the flavor does not disappoint! You get theweetness from brown sugar and honey, balanced out by the zippy tang of mustard and spices. Each taste makes your tastebuds rejoice.

                    I love the addition of cider vinegar – it gives the mustard a delicious fruity undertone. And the texture is phenomenal. Silky smooth and just thick enough to adhere perfectly to any food without being gloppy. Honeycup nails the trifecta of taste, texture and appearance.

                    In my opinion, this is the ultimate honey mustard for chicken nuggets and fingers. That touch of sweetness paired with the slight acidic tang takes boring frozen chicken from bland to bold flavor. But it’s also fantastic on turkey sandwiches, hot dogs, as a salad topper and more! The options are endless.

                    Treat yourself to a condiment that adds a touch of sweetness to brighten your day. Once you try Honeycup Honey Mustard, you’ll never go back to plain yellow mustard again!

                    Koops’ Honey Mustard: Bold, Mouthwatering Flavor in Every Bite

                    Koops' Honey Mustard – Gourmet Mustard, Gluten-Free, Kosher, Made in USA, From Quality Mustard Seeds, Honey Mustard Sauce – 12 Oz, Pack of 1

                      For a honey mustard that packs big, bold flavor into every bite, Koops’ Honey Mustard is my top choice. The combination of ingredients creates a mouthwatering taste that enhances sandwiches, chicken and more.

                      As soon as I opened the bottle, I noticed the pretty golden hue reminiscent of freshly harvested honey. The smooth squeeze bottle makes it so easy to drizzle on top of any dish. And the flavor – wow! You get sweetness from honey plus brown sugar, balanced out by the zip and tang of mustard, vinegar and spices. Each taste is a party for your tastebuds!

                      The texture hits that ideal sweet spot of being just thick enough to cling to food without dripping everywhere. And you can really taste the quality ingredients like mustard seeds, cider vinegar, and real honey. No artificial flavors or thickeners.

                      I love using this honey mustard to punch up basic chicken sandwiches and burgers. The addition of sweet and tangy flavor takes them from boring to bold. It’s also fantastic as a dip for appetizers like soft pretzels. And don’t get me started on how good it is paired with crispy fried chicken tenders!

                      For a bold, mouthwatering honey mustard made with simple, natural ingredients, Koops’ brand is the way to go. Your tastebuds will thank you with each tangy, sweet bite. Try it today!

                      Honey Mustard Buying Guide

                      When evaluating different honey mustards, here are some key factors to consider:


                      Checking the ingredient list on a honey mustard label will tell you a lot about the quality and flavor of the product. Here are some things to look for:

                      • Mustard – A good honey mustard should have mustard high up on the ingredients list, ideally made from mustard seeds rather than mustard powder. This will provide the characteristic tang.
                      • Honey – Real honey is ideal, rather than corn syrup or other sweeteners. Raw or organic honey gives the best natural sweetness.
                      • Spices and herbs – Spices like cumin, paprika, garlic and herbs like basil, oregano or chives can add nice flavor layers.
                      • Oil – Quality oils like olive, avocado or sunflower oil make for a smoother, creamier texture.
                      • Low sodium – Try to avoid products with excessive salt or preservatives.
                      • No high fructose corn syrup – HFCS provides empty calories without benefits.

                      When buying honey mustard, a short, simple ingredient list usually indicates a fresher, more natural product. Watch out for excessive sugar, fillers and preservatives.


                      Do you prefer a thicker, more spreadable honey mustard or a smoother, pourable consistency? Consider the texture you plan to use it for.

                      • Thick honey mustard holds its shape better for slathering on sandwiches or as a veggie dip.
                      • Smooth, creamy honey mustard is great for mixing into dressings, marinades and sauces or drizzling delicately over food.

                      No matter your texture preference, a quality honey mustard should feel smooth, with the ingredients emulsified rather than separated.


                      Since you’ll be eating it, taste is an important factor! The perfect honey mustard has the right balance of sweetness, tanginess and spice flavors.

                      • It should taste predominantly sweet, thanks to the honey, with the savory mustard kicking in after.
                      • The ideal honey to mustard ratio comes down to personal taste – try a few options to see what you like best.
                      • A slight vinegar taste gives it some zing.
                      • Moderate spice from mustard seeds or herbs lifts the flavor.
                      • Avoid honey mustards that are too cloyingly sweet or intensely hot.

                      You can often find sample tastes of different honey mustards at specialty food stores to discover your favorite flavor profile before buying.


                      Honey mustard prices range from $2 to $6 for an average 12 ounce bottle. In general, you’ll pay more for:

                      • Organic ingredients – organic honey and oils will increase cost.
                      • Specialty flavors – unique spice blends or ingredients.
                      • Artisanal brands – small batch, handcrafted.

                      That said, you can find high quality, great-tasting conventional honey mustards for under $3. Sale prices and store brands can also be a good value.

                      Consider how often you plan to use it – an everyday table condiment calls for a more affordable option, while a unique finishing touch for charcuterie deserves a pricier gourmet product.

                      Recommended Honey Mustard Brands

                      To help you get started, here are some top honey mustard options to try:


                      This classic American brand offers a no-fuss yellow mustard tang balanced by sweet honey. The smooth, mild flavor pairs perfectly with everything from chicken fingers to soft pretzels for dipping. French’s honey mustard is inexpensive at around $2 per bottle yet tastes like a pricier gourmet product. You can find it in any grocery store.

                      Annie’s Naturals Organic

                      For an organic choice made with quality ingredients like brown rice syrup, Annie’s Naturals honey mustard has a pleasantly grainy texture. It tastes bright and tangy with the right honey sweetness. At around $4 per bottle, this is a good everyday option for the health-conscious. Sold at natural food stores and many grocers.

                      Mount Horeb Mustard Museum

                      For adventurous flavor, the Mount Horeb Mustard Museum in Wisconsin offers an incredible array of artisanal honey mustards. The maple honey mustard incorporates sweet maple syrup while stoneground mustard seeds provide texture. At $5.50 a jar, it makes a unique gift or special treat for yourself. Order online or visit the museum gift shop.

                      Stonewall Kitchen

                      This Maine-based specialty food company produces delicious small-batch honey mustards like their Wildflower Honey Mustard with a luscious wildflower honey taste. Expect to pay around $6 for a 10 ounce jar. Find it online or at specialty retailers like Whole Foods, Sur La Table and Crate & Barrel.

                      Maille Honey Dijon

                      Imported from France, Maille’s Dijon Honey Mustard is on the pricier side at $6 per 8 ounce jar but offers an exceptional gourmet flavor. The smooth, creamy texture pairs perfectly with higher-end dishes like glazed salmon or chicken marsala. Find Maille at stores like Whole Foods or online retailers.

                      Honey Mustard FAQ

                      Still have some questions about finding and using your ideal honey mustard? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:

                      How long does honey mustard last when unopened?

                      Properly stored in a cool, dry pantry, unopened honey mustard will generally last 1 to 2 years before going bad. Refrigerating after opening extends shelf life 3-4 months.

                      What’s the difference between honey mustard and honey Dijon mustard?

                      While quite similar, Dijon honey mustard tends to use spicier brown or whole-grain Dijon mustard seeds vs regular yellow mustard in traditional honey mustard. Dijon honey mustard also often includes white wine or champagne vinegar for added bite.

                      What are some tasty ways to use honey mustard?

                      Beyond a sandwich condiment or dip, honey mustard can be used to make salad dressings, marinades or glazes for proteins. Whisk it into pan sauces, vinaigrettes or pasta dishes. Baked chicken or fish are delicious brushed with a 50/50 mixture of honey mustard and mayo.

                      Is honey mustard spicy?

                      Most commercial honey mustards offer only a mild spice level to appeal to a wide range of palates. However, you can add a pinch of cayenne pepper or hot sauce to any honey mustard you want to give a spicy kick. Or seek out specialty spicy honey mustards from artisanal producers.

                      Can you substitute yellow mustard and honey?

                      In a pinch, you can mimic honey mustard by stirring 2 tablespoons honey into 1/4 cup yellow mustard. Add a splash of vinegar or lemon juice to brighten the flavor. However, the texture and overall taste will be somewhat different than true readymade honey mustard.


                      With so many tasty honey mustard possibilities, there’s a perfect bottled blend out there for every palate. This guide outlines what to look for when buying the best honey mustard to suit your cooking needs and flavor preferences. A quality product balances sweet honey with zesty mustard tang, has a pleasing texture, and uses natural, high-quality ingredients.

                      Try some of our recommended brands like French’s classic squeeze bottle to Annie’s Naturals organic option to gourmet choices from Stonewall Kitchen and Maille. Or get adventurous with small-batch local finds.

                      Keep an eye out for sales and coupons to get top value. Then slather your favorite honey mustard onto sandwiches, mix it into dips and dressings, or use it as a flavor-packed ingredient in recipes. With the right honey mustard in your pantry, you can add sweet, savory punch to all kinds of foods at home.


                      1. The Recipe Critic: This website provides a recipe for homemade honey mustard sauce that is easy, sweet, and creamy. The recipe uses simple ingredients like honey, Dijon mustard, mayonnaise, and lemon juice to create a delicious sauce that can be used on salads, meat, and veggies.
                      2. Pinch of Yum: This website provides a 5-minute recipe for honey mustard sauce that is sweet, creamy, and perfect for dipping. The recipe uses honey, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, white distilled vinegar, and cayenne pepper to create a flavorful sauce that can be enjoyed with chicken nuggets, as a marinade, or tossed with veggies.
                      3. Allrecipes: This website provides a recipe for Yummy Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce that is made with yellow and Dijon mustards, honey, mayonnaise, and lemon juice. The recipe is simple to make and great for dipping chicken nuggets, veggies, or as a marinade.
                      4. Inspired Taste: This website provides a recipe for Honey Mustard Dressing that is better than store-bought. The recipe uses real ingredients like creamy Dijon mustard, honey, and apple cider vinegar to create a lightened-up dressing that can be used for salads and as a dipping sauce. The website also includes helpful tips for making the dressing and storing it in the fridge.
                      5. Watch Learn Eat: This website provides a vegan recipe for Honey Mustard Dressing and Dip that is oil-free and low in fat. The recipe uses simple ingredients like agave nectar, yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, and turmeric to create a delicious vegan alternative to traditional honey mustard.
                      Articles: 184